Publicação
Does monetary punishment crowd out pro-social motivation? the case of hospital bed-blocking
| Resumo: | We study whether the use of explicit monetary incentives might be counter-productive. In particular, we focus on the effect of fining owners of long-term care institutions who prolong length of stay at hospitals. We outline a simple theoretical model, based on motivational crowding theory, deriving the conditions for explicit monetary incentives to have potentially counterproductive effects. In the empirical part, we exploit a natural experiment involving changes in the catchments areas of two large Norwegian hospitals. We find that bed-blocking is reduced when transferring long-term care providers from a hospital using monetary fines to prevent bed-blocking to a hospital not relying on this incentive scheme, and vice versa. We interpret these results as examples of monetary incentives crowding out agents’ intrinsic motivation, leading to a reduction in effort. |
|---|---|
| Autores principais: | Holmås, Tor Helge |
| Outros Autores: | Kjerstad, Egil; Lurås, Hilde; Straume, Odd Rune |
| Assunto: | Motivation crowding Intrinsic motivation Monetary punishment Hospital bed blocking |
| Ano: | 2008 |
| País: | Portugal |
| Tipo de documento: | working paper |
| Tipo de acesso: | acesso aberto |
| Instituição associada: | Universidade do Minho |
| Idioma: | inglês |
| Origem: | RepositóriUM - Universidade do Minho |
Registos relacionados
article Does monetary punishment crowd out pro-social motivation? A natural experiment on hospital length of stay
por: Holmås, Tor Helge
Publicado em: (2010)
por: Holmås, Tor Helge
Publicado em: (2010)
article The impact of government spending on the private sector : crowding-out versus crowding-in effects
por: Furceri, Davide
Publicado em: (2011)
por: Furceri, Davide
Publicado em: (2011)
article Effects of leadership and reward systems on employees' motivation and job satisfaction: an application to the Portuguese textile industry
por: Leitão, Mariana
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Leitão, Mariana
Publicado em: (2022)
article Experimental investigation of the bed joint influence on mechanical properties of hollow calcium silicate block masonry
por: Zavalis, Robertas
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Zavalis, Robertas
Publicado em: (2018)
article How job characteristics influence healthcare workers’ happiness: A serial mediation path based on autonomous motivation and adaptive performance
por: Junça Silva, A.
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Junça Silva, A.
Publicado em: (2022)
article Preliminary validation study of the intrinsic religious motivation scale and the centrality of religiosity scale for the Portuguese population
por: Araújo, Pedro
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Araújo, Pedro
Publicado em: (2021)
school Incentivos extrínsecos e o efeito de crowding-out nas organizações
por: Leig, Gustavo Guilherme Torrano
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Leig, Gustavo Guilherme Torrano
Publicado em: (2018)
article Are Portuguese Higher Education Students Motivated to Study English as a Second/Foreign Language?
por: Bessa, Luciana Cabral B.
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Bessa, Luciana Cabral B.
Publicado em: (2024)
article Plato’s theory of punishment in book IX of Laws
por: Cunha, Silvia Regina da Silva Barros da
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Cunha, Silvia Regina da Silva Barros da
Publicado em: (2017)
article Teachers’ motivation for teaching in higher education: Portuguese validation of a questionnaire
por: Almeida, Leandro S.
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Almeida, Leandro S.
Publicado em: (2021)
draft Preschool education in Brazil: does public supply crowd out private enrollment?
por: Bastos, Paulo
Publicado em: (2013)
por: Bastos, Paulo
Publicado em: (2013)
article The students’ intrinsic motivation for learning non-financial information matters from their self-identification as global citizens
por: Albuquerque, Fábio
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Albuquerque, Fábio
Publicado em: (2023)
article Reward from punishment does not emerge at all costs
por: Vukov, Jeromos
Publicado em: (2013)
por: Vukov, Jeromos
Publicado em: (2013)
book Punisher : Si vis pacem, para bellum
por: Duarte, José
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Duarte, José
Publicado em: (2019)
article Validation of the Portuguese version of Hoge Intrinsic Motivation Religiosity Scale and Rohrbaugh and Jessor Religiosity Scale
por: Leite, Ângela
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Leite, Ângela
Publicado em: (2024)
article Mobile crowdSensing privacy
por: Guarda, Teresa
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Guarda, Teresa
Publicado em: (2019)
article Punishment should fit the crime : an assessment of the French reform of minimum mandatory penalties
por: Deffains, Bruno
Publicado em: (2009)
por: Deffains, Bruno
Publicado em: (2009)
article Gamification as a learning tool
por: Lopes, Rui Pedro
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Lopes, Rui Pedro
Publicado em: (2014)
school Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations to volunteer work : exploring the effects for flourishing and organizational citizenship behavior
por: Jesus, Maria Margarida Correia de
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Jesus, Maria Margarida Correia de
Publicado em: (2024)
school O papel moderador da empresa na relação entre insegurança laboral e motivação dos colaboradores
por: Casanova, Jéssica Pinheiro
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Casanova, Jéssica Pinheiro
Publicado em: (2020)
article Preschool education in Brazil: does public supply crowd out private enrollment?
por: Bastos, Paulo
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Bastos, Paulo
Publicado em: (2016)
article From Bluetooth naming to crowd interaction
por: José, Rui
Publicado em: (2009)
por: José, Rui
Publicado em: (2009)
school Plan to improve the motivation of employees at Jiangsu Xingchang Human Resources Service Co., Ltd.
por: Laichun Hu
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Laichun Hu
Publicado em: (2024)
school A study on the perceptions of child welfare workers on the use of corporal punishment among immigrant and Norwegian families
por: Alfonso, Nathalia Patricia Perez
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Alfonso, Nathalia Patricia Perez
Publicado em: (2016)
school Análise do efeito do sistema de recompensas na motivação dos colaboradores do grupo “Good Gastronomy”
por: Santos, Adriele Valéria Pereira dos
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Santos, Adriele Valéria Pereira dos
Publicado em: (2017)
school Intrinsic motivation in the age of ai: a self-determination theory perspective
por: Wright, Michael Jonathan
Publicado em: (2025)
por: Wright, Michael Jonathan
Publicado em: (2025)
school Exploring strategies to improve employee motivation: A case study of Jiangsu Xingchang Human Resources Service Co., Ltd.
por: Laichun Hu
Publicado em: (2025)
por: Laichun Hu
Publicado em: (2025)
article Minor narratives: Extrajudicial punishment of youth offenders by police officers in Portugal
por: Zoettl, P. A.
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Zoettl, P. A.
Publicado em: (2017)
article Understanding how and why people participate in crowd events
por: Torres, Eduardo Cintra
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Torres, Eduardo Cintra
Publicado em: (2018)
draft Crowding and tail risk in momentum returns
por: Barroso, Pedro
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Barroso, Pedro
Publicado em: (2020)
school Sweden's Chinese immigrant parents' view on corporal punishment of children
por: Na, Zhongyuan
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Na, Zhongyuan
Publicado em: (2016)
article Understanding how and why people participate in crowd events
por: Costa-Lopes, Rui
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Costa-Lopes, Rui
Publicado em: (2018)
school O efeito das recompensas extrínsecas e intrínsecas na retenção da geração Millennial em consultoria: o papel da motivação e do envolvimento no trabalho
por: Teles, Catarina Selas Mateus
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Teles, Catarina Selas Mateus
Publicado em: (2023)
school O trabalho de projeto como facilitador do desenvolvimento da motivação dos alunos
por: Marques, Ana Catarina Morais
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Marques, Ana Catarina Morais
Publicado em: (2014)
school The impact of coaching on work-family enrichment: The role of intrinsic motivation and self-efficacy
por: Delgado, Ana Soraia Abreu
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Delgado, Ana Soraia Abreu
Publicado em: (2022)
groups Distributed crowd-based annotation of soccer games using mobile devices
por: Barros, B.
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Barros, B.
Publicado em: (2018)
school Prática de ensino supervisionado no 1.º e 2.º ciclo do ensino básico: contributo das atividades práticas e experimentais em ciências para o aumento da motivação dos alunos
por: Dias, Diana Isabel
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Dias, Diana Isabel
Publicado em: (2014)
school Smart tourism toolkit for crowd-monitoring solutions
por: Santos, Tomás Miguel Mestre dos
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Santos, Tomás Miguel Mestre dos
Publicado em: (2023)
article Crowding in during the seven years’ war
por: Palma, Nuno
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Palma, Nuno
Publicado em: (2024)
school Disrupting billion dollar industries by leveraging the crowd : key success factors for business models that rely on crowdsourcing
por: Krätzschmar, Markus
Publicado em: (2015)
por: Krätzschmar, Markus
Publicado em: (2015)
Registos relacionados
-
article Does monetary punishment crowd out pro-social motivation? A natural experiment on hospital length of stay
por: Holmås, Tor Helge
Publicado em: (2010) -
article The impact of government spending on the private sector : crowding-out versus crowding-in effects
por: Furceri, Davide
Publicado em: (2011) -
article Effects of leadership and reward systems on employees' motivation and job satisfaction: an application to the Portuguese textile industry
por: Leitão, Mariana
Publicado em: (2022) -
article Experimental investigation of the bed joint influence on mechanical properties of hollow calcium silicate block masonry
por: Zavalis, Robertas
Publicado em: (2018) -
article How job characteristics influence healthcare workers’ happiness: A serial mediation path based on autonomous motivation and adaptive performance
por: Junça Silva, A.
Publicado em: (2022)