Publicação
Productivity without merit: The hidden costs of academic inbreeding
| Resumo: | This letter responds to Victoria Slepykh’s study on academic inbreeding and early-career productivity, acknowledging its empirical rigor while questioning its central methodological premise: the use of publication counts as the primary proxy for scientific productivity. Although such metrics are appealing for their clarity and comparability, they risk conflating quantity with quality and scientific impact, thereby obscuring the multiple and severe risks associated with academic inbreeding, particularly those affecting institutional integrity. The case of Portugal, where academic inbreeding rates approach 70%, is used to illustrate that high publication output can coexist with comparatively modest levels of international scientific distinction. |
|---|---|
| Autores principais: | Pacheco-Torgal, F. |
| Assunto: | Academic inbreeding research productivity publication counts research quality scientific impact Engenharia e Tecnologia::Engenharia Civil |
| Ano: | 2026 |
| País: | Portugal |
| Tipo de documento: | outro |
| Tipo de acesso: | acesso aberto |
| Instituição associada: | Universidade do Minho |
| Idioma: | inglês |
| Origem: | RepositóriUM - Universidade do Minho |
Registos relacionados
article Academic inbreeding and choice of strategic research approaches
por: Horta, H.
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Horta, H.
Publicado em: (2022)
article Academic inbreeding: exploring its characteristics and rationale in Japanese universities using a qualitative perspective
por: Horta, H
Publicado em: (2011)
por: Horta, H
Publicado em: (2011)
book Academic inbreeding in Portugal
por: Tavares, Orlanda
Publicado em: (2025)
por: Tavares, Orlanda
Publicado em: (2025)
article Determinants of peer review engagement and quality in scientific journals: Insights for academic research and the sustainability of the peer-review system
por: Horta, H.
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Horta, H.
Publicado em: (2024)
article Academic freedom as a defensive right
por: Stachowiak-Kudła, Monika
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Stachowiak-Kudła, Monika
Publicado em: (2023)
article “Who Is the FAIRest of Them All?” Authors, Entities, and Journals Regarding FAIR Data Principles
por: Corujo, Luis
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Corujo, Luis
Publicado em: (2022)
article The impact of African science : a bibliometric analysis
por: Confraria, Hugo
Publicado em: (2015)
por: Confraria, Hugo
Publicado em: (2015)
article Organisational factors and academic research agendas: an analysis of academics in the social sciences
por: Horta, H.
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Horta, H.
Publicado em: (2019)
article Career barriers influencing career success: A focus on academics’ perceptions and experiences
por: Santos, Gina Maria Gaio dos
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Santos, Gina Maria Gaio dos
Publicado em: (2016)
article Regional variation of academic spinoffs formation
por: Conceição, O.
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Conceição, O.
Publicado em: (2017)
draft Determinants of citation impact : A comparative analysis of the Global South versus the Global North
por: Confraria, Hugo
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Confraria, Hugo
Publicado em: (2016)
article Can citation metrics predict the true impact of scientific papers?
por: Aroeira, Rita I.
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Aroeira, Rita I.
Publicado em: (2020)
article The relationship between academics’ strategic research agendas and their preferences for basic research, applied research, or experimental development
por: Santos, J. M.
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Santos, J. M.
Publicado em: (2022)
article Determinants of citation impact : A comparative analysis of the Global South versus the Global North
por: Confraria, Hugo
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Confraria, Hugo
Publicado em: (2017)
article Portugal’s rising research in architecture and urbanism: the influence of international research centers and authors
por: D'Almeida, P. B.
Publicado em: (2022)
por: D'Almeida, P. B.
Publicado em: (2022)
article Regional variation of academic spinoffs formation
por: Conceição, Oscarina Susana Vilela
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Conceição, Oscarina Susana Vilela
Publicado em: (2017)
article ‘With a rope around their neck’: grant researchers living in suspended time
por: Araújo, Emília Rodrigues
Publicado em: (2009)
por: Araújo, Emília Rodrigues
Publicado em: (2009)
article Plenary: the challenges of education in engineering, computing and technology without exclusions: innovation in the era of the industrial revolution 4.0.
por: Brito, Claudio R.
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Brito, Claudio R.
Publicado em: (2020)
article Towards a universal and interoperable scientific data model
por: Oliveira, João
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Oliveira, João
Publicado em: (2023)
article Validation criteria for the outcomes of design research
por: Carvalho, João Álvaro
Publicado em: (2012)
por: Carvalho, João Álvaro
Publicado em: (2012)
article Emerging patterns in the academic literature on responsible research and innovation
por: Loureiro, P.
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Loureiro, P.
Publicado em: (2019)
article Evidence-based radiography: A new methodology or the systematisation of an old practice?
por: Abrantes, António
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Abrantes, António
Publicado em: (2020)
article Evidence-based radiography: A new methodology or the systematisation of an old practice?
por: Abrantes, António
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Abrantes, António
Publicado em: (2020)
groups Analysis of research ideas: combining metaphors for research
por: Morais, Ricardo
Publicado em: (2009)
por: Morais, Ricardo
Publicado em: (2009)
article The research agenda setting of higher education researchers
por: Santos, J. M.
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Santos, J. M.
Publicado em: (2018)
article Academic development as educational inquiry? Insights from established practices
por: Hattum-Janssen, Natascha van
Publicado em: (2012)
por: Hattum-Janssen, Natascha van
Publicado em: (2012)
article Research agendas of female and male academics: a new perspective on gender disparities in academia
por: Santos, João M.
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Santos, João M.
Publicado em: (2021)
article Research agendas of female and male academics: a new perspective on gender disparities in academia
por: Santos, J. M.
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Santos, J. M.
Publicado em: (2021)
article Study of genetic diversity of Bisaro pigs breed by pedigree analysis
por: Fernandes, S.D.
Publicado em: (2010)
por: Fernandes, S.D.
Publicado em: (2010)
article Controlling crack formation since early ages: contributions of COST Action TU1404 and research project IntegraCrete
por: Azenha, Miguel
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Azenha, Miguel
Publicado em: (2019)
article Caring at a Distance: Digital Anchors and the Relational Work of Academic Mobility
por: Cara, Olga
Publicado em: (2026)
por: Cara, Olga
Publicado em: (2026)
article Research agendas and culture: a new approach to analysing the academic profession in Asia and Europe
por: Santos, J. M.
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Santos, J. M.
Publicado em: (2022)
article Genetic diversity in the Portuguese Mertolenga Cattle Breed assessed by pedigree analysis
por: Carolino, Nuno
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Carolino, Nuno
Publicado em: (2020)
groups Corporate communication research: in search for its quintessential model
por: Nunes, Tatiana Filipa Gomes
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Nunes, Tatiana Filipa Gomes
Publicado em: (2022)
article The future of engineering education: current challenges and opportunities
por: Brito, Claúdio R.
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Brito, Claúdio R.
Publicado em: (2021)
article A formação de docentes e investigadores e as bibliotecas académicas: Um desafio e uma proposta
por: Revez, Jorge, 1980-
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Revez, Jorge, 1980-
Publicado em: (2014)
article “Caught by the pandemic”: social, academic, and psychological functioning of college students, during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic
por: Campos, Luísa
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Campos, Luísa
Publicado em: (2023)
article The research-teaching nexus from the Portuguese academics’ perspective: a qualitative case study in a school of social sciences and humanities
por: Farcas, D.
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Farcas, D.
Publicado em: (2017)
article Crowdsourcing hypothesis tests: making transparent how design choices shape research results
por: Landy, J. F.
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Landy, J. F.
Publicado em: (2020)
article Spatial patterns of genetic diversity in Mediterranean eagle owl Bubo bubo populations
por: León-Ortega, Mario
Publicado em: (2014)
por: León-Ortega, Mario
Publicado em: (2014)
Registos relacionados
-
article Academic inbreeding and choice of strategic research approaches
por: Horta, H.
Publicado em: (2022) -
article Academic inbreeding: exploring its characteristics and rationale in Japanese universities using a qualitative perspective
por: Horta, H
Publicado em: (2011) -
book Academic inbreeding in Portugal
por: Tavares, Orlanda
Publicado em: (2025) -
article Determinants of peer review engagement and quality in scientific journals: Insights for academic research and the sustainability of the peer-review system
por: Horta, H.
Publicado em: (2024) -
article Academic freedom as a defensive right
por: Stachowiak-Kudła, Monika
Publicado em: (2023)