Publication
Nocebo effect in Parkinson’s disease : a systematic review and meta-analysis
| Summary: | Background: The placebo effect is well recognized in Parkinson’s disease (PD) and is thought to be at least in part the result of an increase in dopaminergic neurotransmission. Its counterpart, the nocebo effect, remains ill-characterized. Objective: To estimate the nocebo response in PD, and characterize its determinants. Methods: Databases were searched up to February 2017. Randomized, parallel-designed, placebo-controlled trials of patients with PD were included. Nocebo response was defined as the proportion of patients experiencing adverse events in the placebo arm. It was further characterized as the proportion of withdrawals, withdrawals due to AE and deaths in the placebo arm. Random-effects meta-analysis was used to pool data. Statistical heterogeneity was assessed with I2 statistic. The same analyses were repeated with data from the intervention arm to provide a term of comparison. Results: We included 239 randomized controlled trials (47,797 participants). Pooled nocebo response was 55,8% (95% CI 51,5%–60,1%, 149 trials; I2=97.5%). 13,9% (95% CI 12,4%– 15,4%, 229 trials; I2=90,54%) patients withdrew from trials, 5,7% (95% CI 5,0%–6,4%, 222 trials; I2=72,44%) did it because of AE and 0,6% (95% CI 0,5%–0,7%, 231 trials; I2=0%) died during follow up. Similar proportions were identified in patients in intervention arms. Conclusion: The magnitude of the nocebo response in parallel-designed randomized clinical trials in PD is substantial. This information should be integrated in the evaluation, planning and designing of future clinical trials. |
|---|---|
| Main Authors: | Rato, Miguel Leal |
| Subject: | Farmacologia clínica Doença de Parkinson Placebo Nocebo |
| Year: | 2017 |
| Country: | Portugal |
| Document type: | master thesis |
| Access type: | restricted access |
| Associated institution: | Universidade de Lisboa |
| Language: | English |
| Origin: | Repositório da Universidade de Lisboa |
Similar Items
article Nocebo response in Parkinson's disease : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Leal Rato, Miguel
Published: (2019)
by: Leal Rato, Miguel
Published: (2019)
school Placebo and nocebo effect of botulinum toxin administration in cervical dystonia : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Rodrigues, Joana Esteves Ribeiro
Published: (2020)
by: Rodrigues, Joana Esteves Ribeiro
Published: (2020)
school The placebo and nocebo effects in Huntington’s Disease : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Santos, Maria José Malho Lucas dos
Published: (2021)
by: Santos, Maria José Malho Lucas dos
Published: (2021)
school Placebo and nocebo responses in tics : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Julião, Sofia Rosado
Published: (2020)
by: Julião, Sofia Rosado
Published: (2020)
school Placebo and nocebo responses in essential tremor : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Freitas, Carolina Madruga
Published: (2019)
by: Freitas, Carolina Madruga
Published: (2019)
school Nocebo response in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Pereira, João Miguel Silva
Published: (2020)
by: Pereira, João Miguel Silva
Published: (2020)
school The placebo and nocebo responses in multiple system atrophy : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Amorim, Afonso Ferreira Pessoa de
Published: (2021)
by: Amorim, Afonso Ferreira Pessoa de
Published: (2021)
article The placebo and nocebo phenomena : their clinical management and impact on treatment outcomes
by: Chavarria, Victor
Published: (2017)
by: Chavarria, Victor
Published: (2017)
school Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials to evaluate the placebo and noncebo responses in Restless legs syndrome
by: Silva, Maria de Azevedo António Machado da, 1992-
Published: (2016)
by: Silva, Maria de Azevedo António Machado da, 1992-
Published: (2016)
school The Lessebo effect in Parkinson’s disease
by: Mestre, Tiago
Published: (2020)
by: Mestre, Tiago
Published: (2020)
school A systematic review of characteristics and validity of monitoring technologies to assess Parkinson’s disease symptoms and signs
by: Cunha, Guilherme Manuel Coelho Santiago Violante da
Published: (2014)
by: Cunha, Guilherme Manuel Coelho Santiago Violante da
Published: (2014)
school A magnitude do efeito placebo no síndrome das pernas Irrequietas
by: Camara, Raquel de Campos Gonçalves Paulinetti da
Published: (2014)
by: Camara, Raquel de Campos Gonçalves Paulinetti da
Published: (2014)
school Magnitude of the placebo response in both safety and efficacy in paediatric patients with severe asthma under therapy with biological agents : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Fernandes, Inês da Cunha
Published: (2023)
by: Fernandes, Inês da Cunha
Published: (2023)
school Risk of developing Parkinson’s disease in bipolar disorder : systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Faustino, Patrícia Ribeiro
Published: (2018)
by: Faustino, Patrícia Ribeiro
Published: (2018)
school Abordagens terapêuticas na doença de Parkinson: intervenção do farmacêutico
by: Baião, Jéssica Sofia Rodrigues
Published: (2025)
by: Baião, Jéssica Sofia Rodrigues
Published: (2025)
school Effect of gut microbiota modulation in Parkinson’s disease : a systematic review and meta-analyses
by: Barata, Ana Raquel Matias
Published: (2023)
by: Barata, Ana Raquel Matias
Published: (2023)
school Atrial fibrillation risk on Parkinson disease : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Cereja, Fátima Alexandra Machado
Published: (2021)
by: Cereja, Fátima Alexandra Machado
Published: (2021)
article A banha da cobra - uma patranha com história
by: Mesquita, José Carlos Vilhena
Published: (2017)
by: Mesquita, José Carlos Vilhena
Published: (2017)
school Terapia génica no tratamento da doença de Parkinson
by: Fontes, Albina de Jesus Ventura
Published: (2011)
by: Fontes, Albina de Jesus Ventura
Published: (2011)
article Frequency of dementia in Parkinson's disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Severiano e Sousa, Catarina
Published: (2022)
by: Severiano e Sousa, Catarina
Published: (2022)
school Efficacy of pharmacologic interventions for depression in Parkinson’s disease : a cochrane systematic review and network meta-analysis
by: Alves, Nuno Duarte Ascensão Rodrigues
Published: (2021)
by: Alves, Nuno Duarte Ascensão Rodrigues
Published: (2021)
school Tolerability of pharmacologic interventions for depression in Parkinson's disease : a Cochrane systematic review and network meta-analysis
by: Santos, Francisco Correia dos
Published: (2021)
by: Santos, Francisco Correia dos
Published: (2021)
school The sham effect of invasive interventions in chronic coronary syndromes : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Palma, Catarina Filipa Correia
Published: (2021)
by: Palma, Catarina Filipa Correia
Published: (2021)
article The effect of catheter-based sham renal denervation in hypertension: systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Fernandes, Adriana
Published: (2023)
by: Fernandes, Adriana
Published: (2023)
school Clinical practice guidelines for management of parkinson’s disease : a systematic critical appraisal
by: Duarte, Ivo Miguel Santos
Published: (2014)
by: Duarte, Ivo Miguel Santos
Published: (2014)
school Systematic comparison of the effects of α-synuclein mutations on aggregation in Parkinson’s Diseases
by: Lázaro, Diana Fernandes
Published: (2012)
by: Lázaro, Diana Fernandes
Published: (2012)
article Parkinson’s Disease: Clinical Review and Update
by: Cabreira, Verónica
Published: (2019)
by: Cabreira, Verónica
Published: (2019)
article Atrial fibrillation risk on Parkinson’s disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Cereja, Fátima
Published: (2023)
by: Cereja, Fátima
Published: (2023)
school The effect of catheter-based sham renal sympathetic denervation in hypertension : systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Fernandes, Adriana da Silva Ferreira
Published: (2022)
by: Fernandes, Adriana da Silva Ferreira
Published: (2022)
school Is there a role for architecture and design in the management of Parkinson’s disease? : a systematic review
by: Ramos, Joana Liani Beisl
Published: (2018)
by: Ramos, Joana Liani Beisl
Published: (2018)
school Physical exercise for treatment of Parkinson’s disease : a systematic review of clinical trials
by: Silva, Cláudia Sofia Mourato da
Published: (2019)
by: Silva, Cláudia Sofia Mourato da
Published: (2019)
school The efficacy of exercise interventions for people with Parkinson´s disease : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Rosário, Ana Filipa Lopes, 1986-
Published: (2019)
by: Rosário, Ana Filipa Lopes, 1986-
Published: (2019)
article Caffeine exposure and the risk of Parkinson's disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies
by: Costa, João
Published: (2010)
by: Costa, João
Published: (2010)
article Does Parkinson's disease increase the risk of cardiovascular events? A systematic review and meta‐analysis
by: Alves, Mariana
Published: (2019)
by: Alves, Mariana
Published: (2019)
category ISBE & Cochrane Portugal Newsletter nº 324: Antidepressivos na perturbação de ansiedade generalizada
by: Carneiro, António Vaz
Published: (2025)
by: Carneiro, António Vaz
Published: (2025)
school Incidence of muscle symptoms in placebo arm among statin-intolerant patients : systematic review with meta-analysis
by: Louro, Rita Batista
Published: (2022)
by: Louro, Rita Batista
Published: (2022)
school Placebo effect in essential tremor : a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
by: Rufino, João José dos Reis Andrade
Published: (2015)
by: Rufino, João José dos Reis Andrade
Published: (2015)
school Later stages of parkinson’s disease
by: Coelho, Miguel Vilhena Soares, 1972-
Published: (2016)
by: Coelho, Miguel Vilhena Soares, 1972-
Published: (2016)
school Designing a platform for the clinical assessment of Parkinson's Disease with inertial sensors
by: Mendes, César Filipe Oliveira
Published: (2018)
by: Mendes, César Filipe Oliveira
Published: (2018)
article Reliability and Validity of 39-Item Parkinson’s Disease Questionnaire and Parkinson’s Disease Quality of Life Questionnaire
by: Jesus-Ribeiro, Joana
Published: (2017)
by: Jesus-Ribeiro, Joana
Published: (2017)
Similar Items
-
article Nocebo response in Parkinson's disease : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Leal Rato, Miguel
Published: (2019) -
school Placebo and nocebo effect of botulinum toxin administration in cervical dystonia : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Rodrigues, Joana Esteves Ribeiro
Published: (2020) -
school The placebo and nocebo effects in Huntington’s Disease : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Santos, Maria José Malho Lucas dos
Published: (2021) -
school Placebo and nocebo responses in tics : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Julião, Sofia Rosado
Published: (2020) -
school Placebo and nocebo responses in essential tremor : a systematic review and meta-analysis
by: Freitas, Carolina Madruga
Published: (2019)