Publicação
Tradeoffs and theory: The double-mediation model
| Resumo: | Most theories of decision making suggest that, when options imply tradeoffs between their attributes, conflict increases as tradeoff size increases, because greater sacrifices are to be incurred in choosing one option instead of another. An alternative view is that conflict decreases as tradeoff size increases, because stronger arguments can be made for any decision. The authors propose a unified model, the double-mediation model, which combines the mediating effects of sacrifice and argumentation. Our model generally predicts an inverse U-shaped relation between tradeoff size and conflict. Results support this prediction. Also, when the decision situation increases the mediating effect of sacrifice relative to that of argumentation, the relation between tradeoff size and conflict changes in an upward direction; conversely, when the decision situation increases the mediating effect of argumentation relative to that of sacrifice, the relation changes in a downward direction. Results support these predictions as well. Commonalities and differences between our model and other formulations are discussed. |
|---|---|
| Autores principais: | Scholten, Marc |
| Outros Autores: | Sherman, Steven J. |
| Assunto: | Arguments Conflict Decision making Models Double mediation model Argumentation Conflict aversion Orientation reaction Vacillation Sacrifice |
| Ano: | 2006 |
| País: | Portugal |
| Tipo de documento: | artigo |
| Tipo de acesso: | acesso aberto |
| Instituição associada: | Ispa-Instituto Universitário |
| Idioma: | inglês |
| Origem: | Repositório do Ispa - Instituto Universitário |
Registos relacionados
school Tradeoffs and conflict in decision making: Development and applications of the double-mediation model
por: Rosa, Inês Ferreira de Oliveira Valente
Publicado em: (2011)
por: Rosa, Inês Ferreira de Oliveira Valente
Publicado em: (2011)
article Argumentation with goals for clinical decision support in multimorbidity
por: Oliveira, Tiago
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Oliveira, Tiago
Publicado em: (2018)
book A formal approach to argumentation in group decision scenarios
por: Neves, José
Publicado em: (2006)
por: Neves, José
Publicado em: (2006)
article Modelling group decision simulation through argumentation
por: Marreiros, Goreti
Publicado em: (2007)
por: Marreiros, Goreti
Publicado em: (2007)
article The missing link : theoretical reflections on decision reconstruction
por: Antunes, Francisco
Publicado em: (2010)
por: Antunes, Francisco
Publicado em: (2010)
article Argumentation-based decision making in ambient intelligence environments
por: Marreiros, Goreti
Publicado em: (2007)
por: Marreiros, Goreti
Publicado em: (2007)
article Supporting argumentation dialogues in group decision support systems: an approach based on dynamic clustering
por: Conceição, Luís
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Conceição, Luís
Publicado em: (2022)
article Romance languages do not have double objects: evidence from European Portuguese and Spanish
por: Gonçalves, Rita
Publicado em: (2015)
por: Gonçalves, Rita
Publicado em: (2015)
article Zombies Slap Back: Why the Anti-Zombie Parody Does Not Work
por: Prelević, Duško
Publicado em: (2015)
por: Prelević, Duško
Publicado em: (2015)
article Applying machine learning classifiers in argumentation context
por: Conceição, Luís
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Conceição, Luís
Publicado em: (2021)
article Using argument notation to engineer biological simulations with increased confidence
por: Alden, Kieran
Publicado em: (2015)
por: Alden, Kieran
Publicado em: (2015)
article Arguing with behavior influence: A model for web-based group decision support systems
por: Carneiro, Joao
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Carneiro, Joao
Publicado em: (2019)
article A Pragma-Dialectical Approach to Memory Politics: Spanish Contemporary Memory Politics, Populism Studies, and Argumentative Dialectics
por: Ferreira, Maria
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Ferreira, Maria
Publicado em: (2021)
article UbiGDSS: a theoretical model to predict decision-makers’ satisfaction
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2015)
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2015)
book The logic behind negotiation : from pre-argument reasoning to argument-based negotiation
por: Brito, Luís
Publicado em: (2003)
por: Brito, Luís
Publicado em: (2003)
article Enhancing municipal decision-making through an intelligent conflict support system
por: Gomes, Marco Filipe Vieira
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Gomes, Marco Filipe Vieira
Publicado em: (2016)
article Argumentative procedures in E-commerce environments
por: Novais, Paulo
Publicado em: (2003)
por: Novais, Paulo
Publicado em: (2003)
article Argument-based decision making in ambient intelligence environments
por: Marreiros, Goreti
Publicado em: (2009)
por: Marreiros, Goreti
Publicado em: (2009)
article Intervention in family conflicts through mediation from the comparative perspective of principles of Brazil and Portugal legislation
por: Cruz, Rossana Martingo
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Cruz, Rossana Martingo
Publicado em: (2022)
article Biodiversity and Citizenship in an Argumentative Socioscientific Process
por: Freitas, Anne
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Freitas, Anne
Publicado em: (2023)
article Reputation and trust in the context of logic-based argumentation
por: Novais, Paulo
Publicado em: (2004)
por: Novais, Paulo
Publicado em: (2004)
book Approximation, force argumentative et déixis personnelle dans les discours politiques de commémoration
por: Marques, Aldina
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Marques, Aldina
Publicado em: (2017)
article Overcoming the lack of human-interaction in Ubiquitous Group Decision Support Systems
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2014)
article How the ability to analyse tendencies influences decision satisfaction
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2017)
article Understanding decision quality through satisfaction
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2014)
article The effect of decision satisfaction prediction in argumentation-based negotiation
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2016)
article Quality of knowledge in group decision support systems
por: Lima, Luís
Publicado em: (2009)
por: Lima, Luís
Publicado em: (2009)
article VirtualECare: group decision supported by idea generation and argumentation
por: Costa, Ricardo André Fernandes
Publicado em: (2008)
por: Costa, Ricardo André Fernandes
Publicado em: (2008)
article Quality of information in the context of ambient assisted living
por: Lima, Luís
Publicado em: (2009)
por: Lima, Luís
Publicado em: (2009)
article Response: Commentary: Seeing the conflict: An attentional account of reasoning errors
por: Mata, André
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Mata, André
Publicado em: (2018)
article Portuguese primary school teacher´s argumentation for doing or not doing sex education
por: Anastácio, Zélia
Publicado em: (2005)
por: Anastácio, Zélia
Publicado em: (2005)
article Do flowers change colour?": the importance of teaching science and how it can develop children's argumentation
por: Anastácio, Zélia
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Anastácio, Zélia
Publicado em: (2022)
article The role of graphical calculator in developing mathematical argumentation
por: Magalhães, Maria da Graça
Publicado em: (2012)
por: Magalhães, Maria da Graça
Publicado em: (2012)
article Introducing dynamic argumentation to UbiGDSS
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2016)
article Work–family conflicts, cognitive appraisal, and burnout: testing the mediation effect with structural equation modelling
por: Simães, C.
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Simães, C.
Publicado em: (2021)
school A mediação perspetivada por uma abordagem transformativa promotora de competências pessoais e sociais
por: Mota, Branca Sofia Silva
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Mota, Branca Sofia Silva
Publicado em: (2020)
article Modeling and analysis of Double-Double composite structures integrating piezoelectric materials
por: Lupu, Bogdan D.
Publicado em: (2025)
por: Lupu, Bogdan D.
Publicado em: (2025)
article Intra-university mediation on the road to the sustainable development goals: a systematic review
por: Munuera Gomez, Pilar
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Munuera Gomez, Pilar
Publicado em: (2023)
article Dynamic argumentation in UbiGDSS
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Carneiro, João
Publicado em: (2018)
school Analysing nominal phrase contexts for the automatic extraction of linguistic and lexicographic data
por: López Iglesias, Nerea
Publicado em: (2020)
por: López Iglesias, Nerea
Publicado em: (2020)
Registos relacionados
-
school Tradeoffs and conflict in decision making: Development and applications of the double-mediation model
por: Rosa, Inês Ferreira de Oliveira Valente
Publicado em: (2011) -
article Argumentation with goals for clinical decision support in multimorbidity
por: Oliveira, Tiago
Publicado em: (2018) -
book A formal approach to argumentation in group decision scenarios
por: Neves, José
Publicado em: (2006) -
article Modelling group decision simulation through argumentation
por: Marreiros, Goreti
Publicado em: (2007) -
article The missing link : theoretical reflections on decision reconstruction
por: Antunes, Francisco
Publicado em: (2010)