Publicação
Socrates’kατάβασις and the Sophistic Shades: Education and Democracy
| Resumo: | This article addresses the unusually elaborate dramatic context in Plato’s Protagoras and effect of sophistry on democratic Athens. Because Socrates evokes Odysseus’κατάβασις in the Odyssey to describe the sophists in Callias’house (314c-316b), I propose that Socrates depicts the sophists as bodiless shades residing in Hades. Like the shades dwelling in Hades with no connection to embodied humans on Earth, the sophists in the Protagoras are non-Athenians with no consideration for the democratic body of the Athenian πόλις. I conclude that sophistry can be detrimental to Athenian democracy because it can produce education inequality founded on wealth inequality. |
|---|---|
| Autores principais: | Rojcewicz, Christine |
| Assunto: | Plato Sophistry Homer Literary interpretation Education Politics Democracy |
| Ano: | 2023 |
| País: | Portugal |
| Tipo de documento: | artigo |
| Tipo de acesso: | unknown |
| Instituição associada: | Imprensa da Universidade de Coimbra |
| Idioma: | inglês |
| Origem: | Plato Journal |
Registos relacionados
article The εἰκαστική in Plato's Sophist
por: Oliveira, Lethicia Ouro de
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Oliveira, Lethicia Ouro de
Publicado em: (2014)
article á½¥ÏƒÏ€ÎµÏ á¼´Ï‡Î½ÎµÏƒÎ¹ τοῖς ὀνόμασι. Plutarch’s Cratylus
por: Delle Donne, Carlo
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Delle Donne, Carlo
Publicado em: (2023)
article Sócrates, como Odiseo, invocador de las almas de los muertos (ψυχαγωγεῖ ΣωκÏάτης …á½¥ÏƒÏ€ÎµÏ ÎŸá½‘Î´Ï…ÏƒÏƒÎµÏÏ‚)
por: Bordoy, Francesc Casadesús
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Bordoy, Francesc Casadesús
Publicado em: (2020)
article Triangles, Tropes, and τὰ τοιαʋ ̃τα: A Platonic Trope Theory
por: Buckels, Christopher
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Buckels, Christopher
Publicado em: (2018)
article On φÏσις. What did the Greeks un-derstand by φυσικός?
por: Bernabe, Alberto
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Bernabe, Alberto
Publicado em: (2017)
article ὒπόκÏισις. From the art of performing to the art of deceiving
por: Bezerra do Nascimento Costa, Gustavo
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Bezerra do Nascimento Costa, Gustavo
Publicado em: (2022)
article Phaedo, 69c: why are the βάκχοι the true philosophers?
por: Bernabé Pajares, Alberto
Publicado em: (2015)
por: Bernabé Pajares, Alberto
Publicado em: (2015)
article Place of action and tasks of women: the nature (φÏσις) as a justification of customs (νόμοι) in the Economics, by Xenophon
por: Mafra, Janaína Silveira
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Mafra, Janaína Silveira
Publicado em: (2024)
article ÎΟΥΣ, ÎΟΗΣΒΣ, ÎΟΕΒΠand derivatives, in Plato's Philosophy
por: F. Franco, Irley
Publicado em: (2026)
por: F. Franco, Irley
Publicado em: (2026)
article After Socrates “ A Trilogy: (i) Remembering Socrates
por: da Costa Assunção Cecílio, Guilherme
Publicado em: (2018)
por: da Costa Assunção Cecílio, Guilherme
Publicado em: (2018)
article Numenius interpreter of the Timaeus. Notes on the exegesis of the verb βλÎπω (frr. 11, 12, 18 Des Places)
por: Volpe, Enrico
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Volpe, Enrico
Publicado em: (2022)
article Plato. Letters: Letter I
por: Lopes, Rodolfo
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Lopes, Rodolfo
Publicado em: (2016)
article I molti imprevisti del Fedro platonico
por: Rossetti, Livio
Publicado em: (2025)
por: Rossetti, Livio
Publicado em: (2025)
article On á¼Î»ÎµÏ…θεÏία, τὸ ζῆν ὡς βοÏλεταί τις, and Virtue in the Aristotelian Theory of Demokratia
por: Wolf, Eduardo
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Wolf, Eduardo
Publicado em: (2024)
article Μονάς and ψυχή in the Phaedo
por: Stone, Sophia
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Stone, Sophia
Publicado em: (2018)
article "I want to die many times if this is true" (Plat., Ap., 41b). Socrates, Palamedes, and the rhetorical exercises in the horizon of the Socratic dialogue
por: Mársico, Claudia
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Mársico, Claudia
Publicado em: (2021)
article Search for single production of vector-like <i>T</i> quarks decaying into <i>Ht</i> or <i>Zt</i> in <i>pp</i> collisions at √<i>s</i>=13 TeV with the ATLAS detector
por: Castro, Nuno Filipe
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Castro, Nuno Filipe
Publicado em: (2023)
article Socratic Dialectic between Philosophy and Politics in Euthydemus 305e5-306d1
por: Swanson, Carrie
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Swanson, Carrie
Publicado em: (2019)
article Plato’s Socrates, Sophistic Antithesis and Scepticism
por: Blyth, Dougal
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Blyth, Dougal
Publicado em: (2019)
article The Common Origins of Philosophical and Political Power in Plato's Gorgias
por: Winn, Lydia
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Winn, Lydia
Publicado em: (2021)
article Who breathes and smells according to Empedocles? On the πάντα of fr. 96. 1 Gallavotti
por: Piergiacomi, Enrico
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Piergiacomi, Enrico
Publicado em: (2022)
article The concept of the Sun as ἡγεμονικόν in the Stoa and in Manilius’Astronomica
por: Boechat, Eduardo
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Boechat, Eduardo
Publicado em: (2017)
article One hypnagogic dream and the I Ching : a plausible interpretation
por: Correia, José Henrique Rocha Dias
Publicado em: (2012)
por: Correia, José Henrique Rocha Dias
Publicado em: (2012)
article Socrates on virtue and selfknowledge in Alcibiades I and Aeschines' Alcibiades
por: Pentassuglio, Francesca
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Pentassuglio, Francesca
Publicado em: (2014)
article The <i>ATO</i> gene family governs <i>Candida albicans</i> colonization in the dysbiotic gastrointestinal tract
por: Alves, Rosana
Publicado em: (2025)
por: Alves, Rosana
Publicado em: (2025)
article I have my eyes fixed ahead : A contribution to the African literary landscape
por: Baleiro, Rita
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Baleiro, Rita
Publicado em: (2023)
article Search for dark matter produced in association with a single top quark and an energetic <i>W</i> boson in √<i>s</i>=13 TeV <i>pp</i> collisions with the ATLAS detector
por: Castro, Nuno Filipe
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Castro, Nuno Filipe
Publicado em: (2023)
article Measurement of the <i>B</i><SUP>0</SUP><i><sub>s</sub></i> → μμ effective lifetime with the ATLAS detector
por: Castro, Nuno Filipe
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Castro, Nuno Filipe
Publicado em: (2023)
article Antibiofilm Effect of Nitric Acid-Functionalized Carbon Nanotube-Based Surfaces against <i>E. coli</i> and <i>S. aureus</i>
por: Rita Santos
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Rita Santos
Publicado em: (2023)
article Proyecto Plutarco (Πλ). Universidad de Córdoba
por: Lesage Gárriga, Luisa
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Lesage Gárriga, Luisa
Publicado em: (2022)
book ESTUDOS I
por: Covas, António
Publicado em: (2004)
por: Covas, António
Publicado em: (2004)
category Liderança I
por: Filomena Jordão
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Filomena Jordão
Publicado em: (2019)
category Cálculo I
por: Oliveira, José J.
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Oliveira, José J.
Publicado em: (2021)
book Prefácio I
por: Stephen R. Stoer
Publicado em: (2004)
por: Stephen R. Stoer
Publicado em: (2004)
category Liderança I
por: Filomena Jordão
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Filomena Jordão
Publicado em: (2021)
article Plato and democracy’s ambiguous beauty (i): the tension between philosophy and democracy
por: Franco de Sá, Alexandre
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Franco de Sá, Alexandre
Publicado em: (2016)
school iTV PREFARC: Arquitectura de recomendações iTV
por: Antunes, Fernando Rodrigo de Matos
Publicado em: (2010)
por: Antunes, Fernando Rodrigo de Matos
Publicado em: (2010)
school Digital twins: should I stay, or should I go?
por: Maria João Couto Monteiro
Publicado em: (2025)
por: Maria João Couto Monteiro
Publicado em: (2025)
school Estudo da Prevalência de S.I. Imagiológica numa População Pediátrica com D.I.I.
por: Duarte Gil Gouveia Alves
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Duarte Gil Gouveia Alves
Publicado em: (2016)
article "I think that I thought I knew, but now I don’t know": the substitution of Real Fábrica das Sedas e as Anexas’History (1734-2025)
por: Teixeira, Pedro
Publicado em: (2025)
por: Teixeira, Pedro
Publicado em: (2025)
Registos relacionados
-
article The εἰκαστική in Plato's Sophist
por: Oliveira, Lethicia Ouro de
Publicado em: (2014) -
article á½¥ÏƒÏ€ÎµÏ á¼´Ï‡Î½ÎµÏƒÎ¹ τοῖς ὀνόμασι. Plutarch’s Cratylus
por: Delle Donne, Carlo
Publicado em: (2023) -
article Sócrates, como Odiseo, invocador de las almas de los muertos (ψυχαγωγεῖ ΣωκÏάτης …á½¥ÏƒÏ€ÎµÏ ÎŸá½‘Î´Ï…ÏƒÏƒÎµÏÏ‚)
por: Bordoy, Francesc Casadesús
Publicado em: (2020) -
article Triangles, Tropes, and τὰ τοιαʋ ̃τα: A Platonic Trope Theory
por: Buckels, Christopher
Publicado em: (2018) -
article On φÏσις. What did the Greeks un-derstand by φυσικός?
por: Bernabe, Alberto
Publicado em: (2017)