Publicação
Quality decreases from introducing patient choice in a National Health Service
| Resumo: | A view often expressed about patient choice of health care providers is that it will increase competition between providers, which benefits the efficiency of the health system. We address here a patient choice initiative, regarding selection of hospital for specialty consultations, in the Portuguese National Health Service (NHS) that has two specific features. The first feature involves shared decision making between patients and GPs, in the choice of hospital for referral, which should be based on publicly available information on “quality”. The second specific feature is that the patient choice initiative did not involve payment changes to NHS hospitals associated with patients’ movements. We show that explaining initial asymmetries in qualities (waiting times) with systematic differences in hospital characteristics (cost advantages and managerial talent) leads to potential asymmetric responses to the introduction of patient choice in the NHS. This implies that the empirical analysis has to accommodate such asymmetries. Explicitly allowing for asymmetries in responses to the policy measure reveals that reactions were indeed different, with top-performance hospitals reducing their qualities (increasing waiting times) after the patient choice initiative was introduced. |
|---|---|
| Autores principais: | Barros, Pedro Pita |
| Assunto: | Hospital quality Patient choice |
| Ano: | 2022 |
| País: | Portugal |
| Tipo de documento: | artigo |
| Tipo de acesso: | acesso restrito |
| Instituição associada: | Universidade de Lisboa |
| Idioma: | inglês |
| Origem: | Repositório da Universidade de Lisboa |
Registos relacionados
draft Hospital Competition in the National Health Service: Evidence from a Patient Choice Reform
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2018)
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2018)
school Patient choice and choice fees in the Portuguese National Health System
por: Matos, João Henrique Ramos Rola Fidalgo de
Publicado em: (2012)
por: Matos, João Henrique Ramos Rola Fidalgo de
Publicado em: (2012)
draft Hospital competition under patient inertia: do switching costs stimulate quality provision?
por: Sá, Luís Carlos Sousa
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Sá, Luís Carlos Sousa
Publicado em: (2019)
article Dynamic hospital competition under rationing by waiting times
por: Sá, Luís
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Sá, Luís
Publicado em: (2019)
draft Quality discrimination in healthcare markets
por: Esteves, Rosa Branca
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Esteves, Rosa Branca
Publicado em: (2022)
article Patient mobility, health care quality and welfare
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2014)
draft Patient mobility, health care quality and welfare
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2011)
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2011)
article The role of perceived housing quality and perceived choice to recovery: An ecological perspective on a housing first program in Lisbon
por: Martins, Paulo Daniel Fernandes
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Martins, Paulo Daniel Fernandes
Publicado em: (2016)
school Patients’ choice between private healthcare providers in Portugal: a healthcare marketing approach
por: Magalhães, Joana Daniela Lopes
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Magalhães, Joana Daniela Lopes
Publicado em: (2021)
draft Patient mobility and health care quality when regions and patients differ in income
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2015)
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2015)
article The anatomy of choice: an analysis of the determinants of local service delivery in Poland
por: Szmigiel-Rawska, Katarzyna
Publicado em: (2021)
por: Szmigiel-Rawska, Katarzyna
Publicado em: (2021)
article Patient mobility and health care quality when regions and patients differ in income
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2016)
article DRIFT: An analysis of outcome framing in intertemporal choice
por: Read, Daniel
Publicado em: (2013)
por: Read, Daniel
Publicado em: (2013)
article Relationship of the nursing practice environment with the quality of care and patients’ safety in primary health care
por: Lucas, Pedro
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Lucas, Pedro
Publicado em: (2023)
article Improving schools through school choice : An experimental study of deferred acceptance
por: Klijn, Flip
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Klijn, Flip
Publicado em: (2020)
draft Improving schools through school choice : an experimental study of deferred acceptance
por: Klijn, Flip
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Klijn, Flip
Publicado em: (2019)
article Quality of life in patients with multiple sclerosis: a study with patients and caregivers
por: Santos, Martim
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Santos, Martim
Publicado em: (2019)
article The principles of person-centredness in quality patient care Evaluation of the Community Pharmacy Services Quality Guidelines in Estonia
por: Sepp, Kristiina
Publicado em: (2022)
por: Sepp, Kristiina
Publicado em: (2022)
article Patients’ illness schemata of hypertension: The role of beliefs for the choice of treatment
por: Figueiras, Maria João
Publicado em: (2010)
por: Figueiras, Maria João
Publicado em: (2010)
article Islam in urban spaces: the residential incorporation and choices of Muslims in Lisbon
por: McGarrigle, Jennifer
Publicado em: (2016)
por: McGarrigle, Jennifer
Publicado em: (2016)
article Peer adoption and development of health innovations by patients: national representative study of 6204 citizens
por: Oliveira, Pedro
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Oliveira, Pedro
Publicado em: (2019)
article Peer adoption and development of health innovations by patients: national representative study of 6204 citizens
por: Oliveira, Pedro
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Oliveira, Pedro
Publicado em: (2019)
article Comparison between five risk assessment methods of patient handling
por: Villarroya, A.
Publicado em: (2016)
por: Villarroya, A.
Publicado em: (2016)
science Patients’ perception of medical care in the hospital environment: the reasons of non-hospitality
por: Castelhano, Laura Marques
Publicado em: (2025)
por: Castelhano, Laura Marques
Publicado em: (2025)
school Assortment optimization under the multi-choice rank list model : practical application at CurveCatch
por: Oliveira, Guilherme da Silva
Publicado em: (2023)
por: Oliveira, Guilherme da Silva
Publicado em: (2023)
article Validity and reliability of the HEMPA method for patient handling assessment
por: Villarroya, A.
Publicado em: (2017)
por: Villarroya, A.
Publicado em: (2017)
article Unmet needs and quality of life in multiple myeloma patients
por: Pereira, M. Graça
Publicado em: (2020)
por: Pereira, M. Graça
Publicado em: (2020)
article Strategic choice of the subsidiaries : contextual and operational factors
por: Couto, João Pedro
Publicado em: (2003)
por: Couto, João Pedro
Publicado em: (2003)
article The patients’ perspective : what causes hospitalizations for ambulatory care sensitive conditions?
por: Siopa, Margarida
Publicado em: (2019)
por: Siopa, Margarida
Publicado em: (2019)
article Psychosocial factors as predictors of quality of life in chronic portuguese patients
por: Vilhena, Estela
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Vilhena, Estela
Publicado em: (2014)
article The hospital survey on patient safety culture in Portuguese hospitals: instrument validity and reliability
por: Eiras, Margarida
Publicado em: (2014)
por: Eiras, Margarida
Publicado em: (2014)
article Irrational choice and the value of information
por: Vasconcelos, Marco
Publicado em: (2015)
por: Vasconcelos, Marco
Publicado em: (2015)
table_chart TINA survey dataset: citizens perceptions of programmatic choice in Germany and Portugal
por: Heyne, Lea
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Heyne, Lea
Publicado em: (2024)
draft Hospital competition and quality with regulated prices
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2008)
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2008)
article Measuring indian patients' satisfaction : a case of private hospitals
por: Ali, S. Samar
Publicado em: (2010)
por: Ali, S. Samar
Publicado em: (2010)
article Bilateral monopolies and location choice
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2004)
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2004)
school The choice between bank and market debt : evidence from sustainable financing instruments
por: Garcia, Clara Brito Abranches
Publicado em: (2024)
por: Garcia, Clara Brito Abranches
Publicado em: (2024)
article The determinants of intergovernmental grants in Portugal: a public choice approach
por: Veiga, Linda Gonçalves
Publicado em: (2004)
por: Veiga, Linda Gonçalves
Publicado em: (2004)
article The determinants of intergovernmental grants in Portugal: a public choice approach
por: Pinho, Maria Manuel
Publicado em: (2005)
por: Pinho, Maria Manuel
Publicado em: (2005)
school Choice architecture in social marketing: a study on health behaviour in Egypt
por: El-Badry, Mona Mohamed Reda
Publicado em: (2025)
por: El-Badry, Mona Mohamed Reda
Publicado em: (2025)
Registos relacionados
-
draft Hospital Competition in the National Health Service: Evidence from a Patient Choice Reform
por: Brekke, Kurt R.
Publicado em: (2018) -
school Patient choice and choice fees in the Portuguese National Health System
por: Matos, João Henrique Ramos Rola Fidalgo de
Publicado em: (2012) -
draft Hospital competition under patient inertia: do switching costs stimulate quality provision?
por: Sá, Luís Carlos Sousa
Publicado em: (2019) -
article Dynamic hospital competition under rationing by waiting times
por: Sá, Luís
Publicado em: (2019) -
draft Quality discrimination in healthcare markets
por: Esteves, Rosa Branca
Publicado em: (2022)